3.1.5.1 Adjunction to X-bar
Let us take an example to demonstrate how this might work. We know that an adjectival phrase can be used to modify a noun, as in:
(31) | a | smart student |
b | vicious dog | |
c | serious mistake |
It is clear that the noun is the head of this construction as it can act as the complement of a determiner and determiners take nominal complements, not adjectival ones:
(32) | a | the [NP serious error] |
b | the [NP error] | |
c | *the [AP serious] |
The bracketed elements in (32a) and (b) have the same distribution and hence we can conclude they have the same categorial status. As this phrase in (32b) contains only a noun, we conclude that it is an NP. In (32c) however, the phrase following the determiner contains only an adjective and is ungrammatical. This clearly has a different distribution to the other two phrases, indicating that the adjective in (32a) is not the head of this phrase.
It is also possible to conclude that the adjective is not a complement of the head noun as it does not follow the noun and as we have seen, in English, all complements follow their heads.
The other possibility is that the adjective functions as a specifier within the NP and as specifiers precede their heads, this seems more likely. Yet there are properties of the adjective that make it an unlikely specifier. As we saw, specifiers of thematic heads tend to be arguments of those heads. The adjective is obviously not an argument of the noun as it does not bear a thematic role assigned by the noun. Furthermore, specifiers are limited to a single occurrence and there cannot be more than one of them:
(33) | a | the letter arrived |
b | the postman arrived | |
c | *the letter the postman arrived |
However, there can be more than one adjectival modifier of a noun:
(34) | a | popular smart student |
b | big evil vicious dog | |
c | solitary disastrous unforgivable serious mistake |
Thus, the adjectival modifier is an adjunct of the noun. We will argue in a later chapter that adjectival modifiers follow the specifier of the NP and hence adjectival phrases are attached in a position between the specifier and the head. As we see in the following, this puts them as adjuncts to the N':
(35) |
The part of the structure containing the AP is recursive with an N' as the mother and an N' as one of the daughters. This means that there is room for more APs, as demonstrated by (36):
(36) |
This could go on indefinitely with each adjunct introducing an N' which itself contains an adjunct and another N' and hence any number of adjuncts could be added to the structure, which appears to be the correct treatment of adjuncts.