4.2.3 Adjunction within the DP
Adjunction within the DP itself is a rather limited phenomenon. We know that APs and PPs act as modifiers of nouns and adjoin within the NP, but these do not adjoin within the DP ever as can be seen by the fact that they never precede determiners or never modify pronouns:
(55) | a | *tall the building | (the tall building) |
b | *he in the smart suit | (the man in the smart suit) |
Certain adverbs may precede determiners and hence might be analysed as DP adjuncts:
(56) | a | not the right answer |
b | only a fool |
However, it is not at all clear that these elements form part of the DP at all as their distribution is more limited than we would expect if they were inside the DP:
(57) | a | this is not the right answer |
b | *not the right answer is 42 | |
(58) | a | only a fool would think that |
b | *I met only a fool |
These observations would be consistent with the idea that these modifiers are not part of the DP at all, but occupy separate positions in the sentence.
There are some cases of modification by an adverb, however, that do seem to behave as though the adverb is part of the DP. This mainly takes place with quantificational determiners, the meaning of which is modified by the adverb:
(59) | a | almost all men have two legs and one head |
b | I like almost all Renaissance paintings |
It seems that such adverbs are adjoined at the DP level, rather than at the D' level as can be seen from the fact that they precede possessives:
(60) | a | almost John’s whole life was spent avoiding work |
b | *his almost whole life … |
Thus, we propose the following analysis for these structures:
(61) |